Wednesday, September 3, 2008

There is not a gene for ratings!

My biggest pet peeve about science presented in the news has to be the "there is a gene for everything" news stories. While I understand genetics, as well as having some background in psychology and behavior, I have to disagree with this idea that is continually being portrayed: that every behavior, disease, or characteristic has a genetic component, and beyond that, we could potentially control our behavior by controlling genes. Yes, science has proven very clearly that there are genetic components to a variety of conditions and diseases, ie. BRCA I (the "breast cancer" gene) is a prime example. Of course genetics and diseases are intimately linked in a wide array of cases. This is indisputable. However, I think what generally is misunderstood is context. Having a gene or not having a particular gene is not a 100% guarantee, in either direction. It, in combination with a great many other factors, can contribute to a phenotype (an observable characteristic). I think this often gets left out of the headlines for the flashier idea that by discovering a gene for something we can cure it. That is simply not true.
While I whole-heartedly believe in a genetic basis of diseases, which has clearly been proven by research, as a scientist I have a bigger problem with the link between genes and behaviors, like alcoholism and most recently monogomy. I think we are always trying to make excused for certain types of behavior and think that genetics are our free pass. While there is absolutely a biological basis of behavior, we come back to the nature vs. nurture debate with this one and have to decide where one takes precedence over the other. Listen people – its just not that easy. Genes encode proteins. Proteins regulate how our body functions. They interact – like crazy! It’s just not so simple as gene = behavior. I think that’s where people get confused. Oversimplification is bad, in science and in most things. So let’s try to stop doing that.

No comments: