Tuesday, September 9, 2008

Addendum to the gene blog

Right, so almost immediately after I posted this I read another story on the gene for obesity and how exercise might be able to "overcome" it. Right. I am 100% sure there is a biological/genetic component to obesity in SOME people. But lets this about it this way: there are 6 billion people on the planet. Our genomes are about 99.9% the same. At no time other than the present has obesity been such an epidemic in our population. Also, no where in the world is obesity as much of an epidemic as it is in the United States. Hmmmm . . . can we expect that genetics are entirely responsible for this phenomenon? Of course environment plays are role in all this, and environment and biology are constantly interacting to produce specific phenotypes, but really, can we even begin to believe that we can hold genetics responsible for what we are seeing in the US population? Think about it.

Wednesday, September 3, 2008

There is not a gene for ratings!

My biggest pet peeve about science presented in the news has to be the "there is a gene for everything" news stories. While I understand genetics, as well as having some background in psychology and behavior, I have to disagree with this idea that is continually being portrayed: that every behavior, disease, or characteristic has a genetic component, and beyond that, we could potentially control our behavior by controlling genes. Yes, science has proven very clearly that there are genetic components to a variety of conditions and diseases, ie. BRCA I (the "breast cancer" gene) is a prime example. Of course genetics and diseases are intimately linked in a wide array of cases. This is indisputable. However, I think what generally is misunderstood is context. Having a gene or not having a particular gene is not a 100% guarantee, in either direction. It, in combination with a great many other factors, can contribute to a phenotype (an observable characteristic). I think this often gets left out of the headlines for the flashier idea that by discovering a gene for something we can cure it. That is simply not true.
While I whole-heartedly believe in a genetic basis of diseases, which has clearly been proven by research, as a scientist I have a bigger problem with the link between genes and behaviors, like alcoholism and most recently monogomy. I think we are always trying to make excused for certain types of behavior and think that genetics are our free pass. While there is absolutely a biological basis of behavior, we come back to the nature vs. nurture debate with this one and have to decide where one takes precedence over the other. Listen people – its just not that easy. Genes encode proteins. Proteins regulate how our body functions. They interact – like crazy! It’s just not so simple as gene = behavior. I think that’s where people get confused. Oversimplification is bad, in science and in most things. So let’s try to stop doing that.

Welcome!

So I am starting this blog because I am so sick and tired of the news media presenting stories about science that are inaccurate, untrue, ridiculous, or only there for entertainment value. Very infrequently do I see true science being reported. I see the news media shows perpetuating inaccuracies and falsehoods to the public because they are looking for ratings and don't truly understand the science. Or, they must think that the public is stupid and can't possibly understand true science in the appropriate context. No Longer! With this blog my goal is to present recent, interesting, or noteworthy scientific news, discoveries, research, etc, in a context that both is understandable to the general public, as well as accurate, without any of the flashy headlines or generalizations that I so often see. I hope that you find this interesting and give me feedback on your interpretation of these news items as well. Enjoy and I hope you learn something!